The PBA "No Harm No Foul" Rule: The Pros and Cons

Mark Barroca and Marc Pingris of Star Hotshots
If the "No Harm No Foul" Rule gets reinstated, defense-oriented teams are among those who will benefit the most. (Photo by the PBA Media Bureau)

Can it actually help bring back the life in the PBA?

Whether you like it or not, basketball is a game that is filled with physicalities and those physicalities are what make the game a bit more exciting and entertaining, to say the least. What's more exciting than seeing stars attacking defenders on their way to the basket, making the basket despite being defended tremendously? 

Or, what about defenders who successfully defended the opposing team's primary scorer especially in critical situations of the game? These are the two things which make basketball more exciting than any other sports in the world.

During the early days of the PBA, physicality was at its best. Players were killing each other just to get things done. Of course, there were dirty plays but it's still part of the game. And whether we like it or not, there will be always dirty players. This led former Commissioner Chito Narvasa implementing stricter rules on calling fouls- removing the "No Harm No Foul" rule in the process. While this move was good in terms of preventing things from escalating, this said move also slowed the game down. And it has made the fans bored and disappointed with the quality of games that they were seeing.

Fortunately, PBA OIC, Willie Marcial said that one of the changes that the league will discuss once the board meets for the time this year is the return of the "No Harm No Foul" rule. According to Mr. Marcial, some members of the board have actually said that they want the games to develop more "color" by allowing more physicalities to come into play.

But of course, it will have both the pros and the cons:

Pro: Faster and More Exciting Games

Assuming that the board agrees to full implementation of the said rule, one of the benefits of doing so is allowing the games themselves to speed up because of the lesser fouls that would be called. With the rule back, fans can now expect more physical plays especially on the defensive end of the game.  This will excite the fans and will encourage them to watch the game live. 

Con: Flops and  Dirty Plays

While the league has said that it will not tolerate dirty plays once the "No Harm No Foul" rule gets implemented anew, there's no denying the fact that dirty plays from dirty players will always stay. 

Now, since getting fouled will be more difficult with the impending return of the rule, flops will come into play more than often. So, implementing the "No Harm No Foul" rule is a double-edged sword. 


Whether bringing back the old rule will help repair the strained relationship between the PBA and the fans is something that we need to wait and see. 

While it's  exciting because it will allow more physicalities, the PBA  still has a more important thing to decide on before anything else: Who will replace Chito Narvasa as the PBA commissioner?


Popular posts from this blog

The PBA Crowd

Lakers Walang Plan B sa coaching search? Si LeBron na Lang kasi..

Xander Zayas Shines in Puerto Rican Day Parade Weekend, Dominates Teixeira

Top Rank Signs Featherweight World Champion Rafael Espinoza to Co-Promotional Contract with Zanfer Promotions

Fresh Beginnings for New Jersey's Own: Vito Mielnicki Jr. Inks Promotional Deal with Top Rank

Hiroshima Dragonflies and Ryukyu Golden Kings to represent Japan in EASL 2024-25 Season

Facebook Timeline